Why do 60% of UK public think overseas Aid is wasted? Part 2

Various Federal Reserve Notes, c.1995. Only th...

Image via Wikipedia

As promised in the last post I am revisiting this question . But before I add my views here is what some of you the readers thought

@JesseOsmun Aid is wasted because it is funneled through goverment hands, with Corruption skimming it instead of direct aid to people

Bob Hayward-Because after years of aid the root cause of the various problems remain unsolved.

Both these points raise interesting points but Bob’s question answers the question

Why do 60% of UK public think overseas Aid is wasted?

Do we actually have proof that overseas Aid is wasted?

If we do have proof of Aid being wasted why is it wasted?

Is it because the UK can actually spare this money?

Is it bad planning?

Is it poor policies?

Is it poor distribution of Aid?

Who is responsible for ensuring that Aid is not wasted?

What can be done to ensure Aid isn’t wasted?

 

Does @JessOsmun have a point? Aid should not go to governments but instead to projects directly?

This point reminds me of a similar scheme here in the UK. Those that cannot afford to cover their housing costs get help from the government, in some case the money goes directly to the landlords.  But can they be trusted to let the government know when the tenant has moved on so that the government stops sending the money?

In other cases  the person(claimant as we call them) is paid housing benefit (money to pay their rent/landlord) directly but the person might chose to divert the money to something else say clothes leaving the landlord out of pocket.

What should the government do to come up with a system that does not produce either of those scenarios?

 

Can you see any similarities between Housing benefit and Overseas Aid?

 

Finally what can done to stop overseas Aid being wasted?

 

I will keep this short so we can have a conversation

Enhanced by Zemanta
Share

What they said about us

Sally Church: Ida is the bees knees of networkers and suppliers, seriously. She is also hard working, kind, thoughtful and a joy to be with. A few days before Christmas, I contected her by email desperate for some beautiful silk scarves from Madagascar for my Mother and Aunt. She had 2 left and promptly dispatched them off to them for me sight unseen. They arrived in time to be greeted with much happiness and thus my honour was restored.Thank you Ida, you made two dear old ladies’ Christmas and I love you for that xx
In case anyone is wondering, the products are beautiful, high quality and reasonably priced. The service is excellent and highly recommended. Awesome, just simply awesome.

Jackie Mitchell JM Communications: Ida Horner is an inspiring individual, who runs Ethnic Supplies to help African women out of poverty. The business sells a range of products via its web site made by poverty-stricken women’s groups from Africa such as beautifully-made costume jewellery, mats, bags and silk scarves, all made by hand using natural materials and methods. Ida provides a dignified and sustainable way out of poverty for thesewomen. She is highly professional in her approach and started her business from scratch. Help her to develop her business by visiting Ethnic Supplies Ltd

The O beaded Bracelet

Emma James: I’ll certainly echo the out of this worldly products. Wonderful! I ordered a beautiful hand made fruit basket and table runners/place mats as a gift for Barbara, my father’s new bride for my recent trip. Inspired choice. Ida is totally professional, friendly and supportive – I’d no idea what to choose, it all looks lovely to me – Ida helped to guide me at my request and despatched it out to Paris for me to save me lugging it over there, even phoning early one morning to say the parcel was en route – that’s dedication for you (she’d have known I was up being an early bird).

multicolour-placemats

In Paris, new daughter-in-law scored high on the leader board. Barbara was delighted with the products. Individual and very high quality. What’s more, it’s a cause dear to Barbara’s heart and I’ve no doubt she will source products from Ida in future too. (My Dad really liked them too, double whammy wink)

Pamela E Fry I bought it from a friends web site! AND it is fantastc for the tropics, keeps your head cool; not like cotton hats xxx

Handmade Straw hat

 

For these and other accessories- please visit our online shop http://ethnicsupplies.co.uk/shop/

 

Enhanced by Zemanta
Share

Do NGOs have a role in food distribution?

This post is also part of the #30 day blogging challenge series and today we are looking at creating catchy headlines. In the last post I asked you what  topics you would like me to cover on this blog and whilst I wait for your ideas I thought I would revisit this question as someone has already asked it

If you have been following the news you would have come across 2 news headlines

  1. News of the World and the phone hacking scandal
  2. Famine at the Horn of Africa

The second headline has almost faded from front line news but is the subject of today’s post.  Folk in East Africa or more preciously the Horn of Africa are facing the worst famine in 60 years and Non Governmental Organisations (NGOs) and Charities are appealing to us to donate whatever we can to support their efforts to get food to these folk

So what is the role of NGO’s in food distribution?

The answer is it all it depends on their terms of reference as NGOs get established for all manner of reasons.

A different question- do NGOs have a role to play in food distribution?

The simple answer is YES and

 

A qualified answer is Yes but perhaps only in emergencies such as the one we are currently witnessing in East Africa.

Why?

In my mind it is because the role of ensuring that citizens are fed primarily rests with leaders of a given country. They ought to plan and manage food distribution- put simply this involves

  1. getting food from where it is to where it is needed
  2. planning for hard times- e.g when the rains fail
  3. supply and managing the infrastructure that enables 1 and 2 to happen

Am I being naive here- well that much depends on your point of view. But there are some things that I would  like you to bear in mind please

  1. One of the countries that are listed amongst those facing severe famine is Uganda, but as you can see from my previous post- there is no shortage of food in Uganda and that being the case why is Uganda included on this list.
  2. granted Somalia- does not have an effective government to speak of but even then, are those in charge in Somalia starving like the millions we have seen trekking across East Africa in search of food. What does this tell us?
  3. these countries are in close proximity to each other- could leaders of these countries get together and plan this out, I am not suggesting here that they should plan for good rains- but we do know that rains in this part of Africa do fail but do the East African leaders have a strategy for dealing with this? Or is it easier to wait and cry for help from the NGOs? I also know that most homes have more food than they need- for instance my mother has more Avocados than she knows what to do with and if someone asked her to donate it to starving people she will part with it easily. The only catch would be that you would need to get it off the trees yourself
  4. why was Kenya’s initial reaction to the catastrophe to deny those fleeing the famine in Somalia access into Kenya?
  5. Uganda has sent her military to rid Somalia of a terrorist cell Alshabab could they send some food to the folk they are trying to protect- chances are these folk are more likely to die of hunger than Alshabab bullets at this rate. Do you agree?

 

Whilst some want to know what the role of NGo’s in this is some like my twitter buddy @mugumya want to know

Patrick MugumyaWhy is it #Africa that is always starving? is it that God is against us, do we sin too much or have we refused to learn from our past?

I am not  so sure about God being against us but I have covered some of the reasons why Africans are always starving in this post some of which include disease and severe weather, you can’t work the land if you body is ridden with parasites. have we refused to learn from our past. It would appear that way seeing us we are aware or at least leaders are aware of what is required but fail to implement or take the necessary steps to secure food for everyone

Another issue that has been bugging me- where is the African diaspora in all this? What aren’t we doing something collectively to aid folk at the horn of Africa?

Whilst we ponder and debate this folk are dying of hunger and they continue to trek to safety

 

Enhanced by Zemanta
Share