Why do 60% of UK public think overseas Aid is wasted? Part 2

Various Federal Reserve Notes, c.1995. Only th...

Image via Wikipedia

As promised in the last post I am revisiting this question . But before I add my views here is what some of you the readers thought

@JesseOsmun Aid is wasted because it is funneled through goverment hands, with Corruption skimming it instead of direct aid to people

Bob Hayward-Because after years of aid the root cause of the various problems remain unsolved.

Both these points raise interesting points but Bob’s question answers the question

Why do 60% of UK public think overseas Aid is wasted?

Do we actually have proof that overseas Aid is wasted?

If we do have proof of Aid being wasted why is it wasted?

Is it because the UK can actually spare this money?

Is it bad planning?

Is it poor policies?

Is it poor distribution of Aid?

Who is responsible for ensuring that Aid is not wasted?

What can be done to ensure Aid isn’t wasted?

 

Does @JessOsmun have a point? Aid should not go to governments but instead to projects directly?

This point reminds me of a similar scheme here in the UK. Those that cannot afford to cover their housing costs get help from the government, in some case the money goes directly to the landlords.  But can they be trusted to let the government know when the tenant has moved on so that the government stops sending the money?

In other cases  the person(claimant as we call them) is paid housing benefit (money to pay their rent/landlord) directly but the person might chose to divert the money to something else say clothes leaving the landlord out of pocket.

What should the government do to come up with a system that does not produce either of those scenarios?

 

Can you see any similarities between Housing benefit and Overseas Aid?

 

Finally what can done to stop overseas Aid being wasted?

 

I will keep this short so we can have a conversation

Enhanced by Zemanta
Share

Villages in Action- the day the villagers had their say

The Villages in Action Conference (VIA), is the brain child of Teddy Ruge of Project Diaspora and was held in Kikuube Village Grounds, Masindi, Uganda on 27 November 2010. The conference was co sponsored by Orange Uganda and Business Fights Poverty Kikuube is a beautiful village in Masindi district western Uganda and is home to at least 1000 people most of whom are farmers. With no running water or electricity, it is the sort of village that the world of development would refer to as remote and impoverished and therefore ripe for the plethora of development programmes. The people of this village would be the first to tell you that they do need help to develop their village but as I found out not the sort of help that denies them an opportunity of having a say on what that looks like. I will now take you through how the actual day went as we gathered to hear the work villagers are doing to develop their village The technology panel

The organizers- PROJECT DIASPORA

Teddy Ruge and his team were motivated by the fact that back in September 2010; the World Leaders came together in New York to discuss the state of the poor. The poor according to the World Leaders are those that live on $1 a day such as the inhabitants of kikuube, they spoke about the poor in their absence, like they didn’t have a voice and referred to them as numbers. Project Diaspora decided that if World Leaders would not invite the poor to their conference perhaps because they do not know who they are, the best thing to do was to bring the conference to the so called poor so that they can tell the world who they are, how they live and the solutions that they come up with to their day to day challenges. Project Diaspora felt that the voice of villages like Kikuube was missing in conversations about development and yet how the village develops depends on the decisions that the villagers take and not those made by the World Bank, nor decision makers in London and New York

Project Diaspora handed the Microphone to some in the village and encouraged them to introduce themselves to world, tell world how intelligent they are and insist that they need to bring change they need to ask the Villagers how they would improve this Village In Action. This single act put the village on world map as the world sat and listened via Social media platforms, such as UStream Video Channel, Twitter and Facebook made possible by WIFI provided by Orange™ Uganda Issues for discussion included; Technology, education, farming and entrepreneurship, small businesses and how that contributes to the well being of the community and health For the purposes of this post I will only draw out the reasons why the sponsors got behind this event, the key points raised by the Local councilor in her speech as well as the local enterprise stories.

The Sponsors- Business Fights Poverty

As the lead sponsor of the event Business Fights Poverty (BFP), their decision to sponsor the event was based on the view that the event provided a unique and powerful way to tell the story of the importance of enterprise for development. Most events on this topic are based in Western capitals, with speakers and attendees drawn from relatively large companies, non-government organizations and governments. Villages In Action would provide an important platform for the voice of poor people in this discussion. BFP is a global network of over 7,000 people from more than 130 countries who believe that the best way to improve lives is by helping entrepreneurs succeed. When businesses grow, they create new opportunities for others – new products, services and jobs. BFP is a community around the world that shares practical ideas about how to fight poverty through good business. Half the members come from business, and the other half from governments, donor agencies, charities and universities.

Orange™ Uganda

Orange™ Uganda played a vital role by providing the technology that made it possible for the world to hear the voices of the people of Kikuube and to watch and participate in the conference via video link and internet access. Orange™ Uganda feel that they have a vital role to play as far as meeting the Millennium Development Goals are concerned and to that they are keen to work with development partners by applying technological services and products that provide new possibilities for communities such as Kikuube. Orange™ Uganda believes that mobile telephony brings people closer and through innovation lives of both urban and rural communities can be improved The Village Voices The Local Councillor- Mrs Milly Businge

Milly Businge

Milly is a formidable African woman, articulate and purposeful. I spent 2 days with her and she left me in no doubt about how much she cares about the development or her village. She is married with 8 children, one of whom is Teddy and is a farmer As she took to the microphone she invited the world to come see how they exist, how empowered they are, how they educate their children as well as how they survive and share in their successes and failures. She was surprised that as Village councillor she had never heard of the Millennium Development Goals (MDGS) even though these had been in place as long ago as the year 2000 and had been set for the benefit of villages like Kikuube. Over the years she has witnessed several government programmes to immunise children, the introduction of universal primary education for all village children as well as programmes on HIV/AIDS but was not aware that this was due to the MDGs as those delivering the programmes did not bother to include them in the planning nor delivery of these programmes in the village. The main occupation in the village is farming especially commercial sugarcane growing that is supplied to Kinyara Sugar Works Ltd.

Milly reported that this has been good for the village as many in the village have access to mobile phones, personal means of transport such as bicycles and motorcycles, many have been able to construct permanent houses as well as send their children to school from the money earned from sugarcane growing. She was surprised to learn that elsewhere in the world people who survive on less than $1 are considered poor and yet some folk survive in the village survive on less than that, through hard work.

In what seemed like a direct message to the community she said

Every society has winners and losers, those that work hard as well as the lazy ones but we are still considered poor. Our fertile ground will feed those who sow and bury those who do not

On the MDGs, she said the village has more or less met the goals concerned with eradicating extreme poverty and hunger and that 75% of the children in the village have access to free education.

Child mortality – the government has made huge strides towards eradication child mortality through immunisation programmes and urged the parents to work with the government in order to achieve this goal. She highlighted some of the key challenges that prevent parents from getting their children immunised • Parents have to travel long distances to access this programmes the nearest facility is 3 miles away, another is 4 miles and whilst another 8 miles • The village culture is that the women take care of the sick, it therefore their duty to travel these long distances to access immunisation • And sometimes they arrive to health centres they discover that the necessary medicines have run out and this leads to child mortality, it will help to bring the health centre facility near

Another challenge facing the community is Environmental sustainability. She said we have a lush green village and it used to be better than this before we started cutting down the trees for charcoal and firewood as well as growing of sugarcane- this has led to the disappearance of woodlands, and loss of rainfall, we would like the world to work with us on programmes on environmental care to help prevent further loss of woodlands

In committing her village to supporting the government to achieve the MDGs she said,

we cannot direct the wind but can adjust the sail,

How does business fight poverty in this village-

Kikuube is a farming community and enterprise evolves around this activity through services and products required by farmers as consumers. I spoke with 3 entrepreneurs in the village and here are their stories

Yossam- the sugarcane grower

Yossam has been involved in sugarcane growing for the last 14 years and this has enabled him to put his 15 children through school and the eldest is currently at University. He is what is known as an out grower for the Kinyara Sugar Works ltd part owned by the government (49%) and the Rai Group (51%). I understood that the government intends to distribute its shares to the Bunyoro Kingdom where Kukuube is located, the employees, the district council and some of the outgrowers. He noted that since privatisation the scales have been tipped in favour of the Rai group at the expense of the growers. I asked him about some of the challenges they face • Access to affordable finance- the growers can only borrow from Kinyara Sugar Works at a rate of 26% and at an 18 month term • This means that the growers are often running at a loss as the struggle to pay back the loans •

Kinyara charges very high for services to the farmers and does not pay on time and when they do 10% of the pay is held back and when this is paid normally a year later no interest is given on that money I asked Yossam whether under the circumstances he considers sugarcane growing a viable business and he said it is near impossible to break even but they do and have managed to • Send their children to school • Build permanent residential homes as well as commercial buildings that they rent out as business premises • Acquire bicycles and motorcycles as a means of personal transport as well as • Pay for health care

James – the grain miller and local bicycle repairer

This is the shed that houses James’ grain mill James is an older man possibly 60 years old and very easy to like and he provides two very vital services to his community. Grain milling- James says that he and his family started this business in 2004 as they wanted something that could bring them a daily income. He decided to call the Business LET US HELP EACH OTHER because he provides a service to the village and in turn that brings him income. The impact of this business on the village is easy to dismiss until you take a closer look.

One of the MDGs is preventing extreme hunger and in this village without electricity or factories to preserve food for leaner times the easiest way to preserve food is turn into flour which is easy to store. The grain miller facility is very simple and is located in what we in the west would consider a shed but has far reaching consequences for those that rely. Bicycle repairing- bicycles are the most common means of personal transport in Kikuube and as any means of transport the bicycles do break down and need repairing. I asked James the significance of bicycle ownership in the village. It enables farmers to get their produce to market without bicycles it would be near impossible as the market is a long a way away nearly half a day’s walk James told me Out of these two services James has been able to sustain his family, pay for health care and education

Pamela- the Hardware shop owner

Pamela is very unusual for an African woman and a sign that times have changed in days gone by she would not have been able to open or own a shop. When I caught up with her I asked her what motivated her to get started and her challenges. She told me simply that she saw a gap in the market as the community prospered, there was an increase in the construction of permanent houses and folk had to travel to nearest town which 45 minutes away so she decided to open hardware shop and on the day she opened the entire stock was bought by the villagers. One of her key challenges is access to affordable finance, which would enable her to buy stock at wholesale prices in Kampala- the capital city of Uganda. Because she doesn’t have substantial assets she would be excluded from borrowing from the local banks.

Some after thoughts

As I left Kikuube, I was in a contemplative mood as I wondered how I personally would cope with challenges such as poor roads, sky high interest rates. I didn’t feel that these were ideal circumstances in which in which to transact business but against all odds folk here were doing their best to lift themselves out of poverty with no intervention from donors but through enterprise. I felt proud to have been there in person as they told the world their story of how they survive day to day, how they help each other to grow and develop. If there was ever a story that proves how private enterprise impacts development, this is it!

The question to the rest of the world is- what are we going to do to ensure that we build on the successes of this VILLAGE IN ACTION!

Share

Villages in Action

Today we welcome Guest blogger Teddy Ruge of Project Diaspora. Teddy is a mobile technology enthusiast and blogs frequently about the African ICT sectors and it’s effects on development. He has served on several panel discussions related to Africa, the role of the African Diaspora and Africa’s emerging technology space.

The Genesis of TEDxPoor that led to a much bigger idea

The idea of TEDxPoor was born out of a Twitter discussion during UN week in September. The ongoing review of the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) left a lot to be desired. For starters, the voices of those that could best benefit from this conversation were left unheard. Too often entire conferences and summits are held on the subject of “the poor” All too often they are discussed as faceless, voiceless individuals who never get an opportunity to participate in the global discussion about them. The discussions on Twitter were that something was decidedly missing from the dialog. Laura Seay, assistant professor of political science at Morehouse College, attended several of the conferences that week and had this to say:

“While there is a lot of discussion of the need to capture human capital in developing countries, we didn’t hear from anyone who had actually lived the experience of escaping poverty. We didn’t learn how families survive on $1 a day from people who have no choice but to make it work.”

In the spirit of the moment and the discussion, I offered to take the microphone to these so-called “poor,” so the world could get a chance to hear their voices and opinions; many of whom have never heard of the MDGs.

TEDx’s online registration application has been offline nearly the whole time. This has provided ample time for me to rethink this whole idea and wether or not a TEDx-branded event in the village was what I was trying to accomplish. Leveraging the TEDx brand absolutely has its advantages. The TED Talks video library is probably the most inspiring online catalog of moving images. The TED conferences have made strides to include voices from the African perspective into its talks. Various African visionaries have shared their inspiring ideas; George Ayitteh, Andrew Mwenda, William Kamkwamba, Chimamanda Adichie, Ory Okolloh and Ngozi Okonjo-Ideal to name but a few. A TED conference was held in Arusha, Tanzania in 2007. I also had the opportunity to speak at TEDxKigali this summer. The TED community even announced a partnership with Nokia to bring bundled TED talks to Africa on Nokia N8 all-in-one phones. These are all great and welcome initiatives, but I am sure you know what I am about to say. We’ve seen this model before. Many times. Successful initiatives imported onto the continent, turning us ever more into consumers and passengers as opposed to mechanics and drivers; spectators to the shaping of our own collective destinies.

Western academics wax poetic about their research methodologies and theories into how or if we (the poor) can achieve the MDGs, even going so far as to engage in intellectual sparring over each other’s development methodologies. Why is our development the rightful occupation of Western academics and armchair development pundits, and the rich and famous? I think they all really miss the point. Albert Einstein once said, “if we knew what we were doing, it wouldn’t be called research.” I am not an academic, nor do I think that I was ever cut out for such a vocation. I am happy being drunk with can-do idealism that things can work much better for those affected, that things could be much simpler; one does not need 15 years or (50 years for that matter) of research figuring out how. Let’s just do it already.

This is a call to action for the creation of a completely new platform. A departure from the norm. Let’s build our own podium; where the world can meet us, the faceless “poor.” While we may not consider ourselves poor, the world, does. I include myself because this is my community, my village, my family. This is a chance for us to contribute our not only our voices to the discussion, but to also showcase what we are already doing to advance our own communities. I think too often the world forgets that there are real people behind the stats, research goals and projections; people with opinions, ideas and smarts. As Seay said, people who, against the odds, thrive earning $1 per day. I think it is time for us to share our ideas on what, (if anything) we can do to participate in our own economic emancipation. Above all, there has to be some value in sharing how we survive averaging $1 per day. If you can do that, are you really poor or an efficient minimalist? While the label of “poor” is generally attached to the those living under the $1 per day economic threshold, is it necessarily a bad thing if you can feed, house, clothe and educate you children? Is it easy to do? Not in the least. Could we stand to rise above that in pursuit of a better quality of life? Absolutely! The state of Poor is relative.

I’ve espoused many times the need for us Africans to politely take over the reigns of our own development. No longer do we need the steadying hand the West has had on our shoulders for half a century. The journey to equilibrium requires that we experience both failure and success to appreciate what balance is. Eventually, we must become the architects of our own development. We must become our own advocates.

Introducing the first Villages in Action Conference
Twenty minutes outside the small town of Masindi, Uganda is a village called Kikuube. There are over 260 homesteads with a population just over 1000. The local council member representing the village is none other than my Mum, whom I am sure you have met. In talking to her about this conference, I was surprised that she—as a village leader—had never heard of the MDGs. Yet she goes about her day fulfilling tasks meant to improve the welfare of her community; from educating her community about the use of bed nets, to regular home inspections enforcing sanitation codes, to empowering women with micro-loan programs. What does it say about the MDGs when the very people that are supposed to be beneficiaries don’t even know about them?

On Saturday, November 27, the microphone will be mounted stage center in this little quaint village. We welcome the world to join us in a frank discussion on the state of poor. We’ll discuss the MDGs and what our role is in achieving them by 2015 (and what we were already doing). Let’s talk about how we survive. How big a role does commercial farming and the various small-scale entrepreneurial activities contribute to our development. I want to challenge the notion that the sustainability of our communities depends on intervention from the West and that we are willing to take up the responsibility of developing and managing ourselves. I’d like the world instead to come to my village (and hopefully soon enough, to other villages) to see how we “manage.” Not in the sense of “poverty tourism,” but in a genuine exercise of actually listening to and engaging with us.

“How can I help,” you ask?
Good question. With such a short throw window, we’ll need all the help we can get. From volunteers, to sponsors, to live tweeters and bloggers. The word needs to get out about this conference, so if you can space a few column inches about this new platform, please do support us with a paragraph or two. A live stream of the summit would be fantastic, so we’ll obviously need tech assistance pulling that off from a remote village. This is not entirely impossible with the right partners in place. So if this is your field, please do get in touch. If you would like to lend us some financial assistance instead, you can do do so at various levels below. We’ll give as much credit as deserved to everyone who contributes to pulling this off. So thanks in advance and do check back in the coming days as more details are released. As expected, we welcome as much Diaspora participation as possible!

Share