Immigrants are not welcome here- part 1

Immigration is back in the news again well what with the general election announced here in the UK. In Saturday’s edition of BBC Radio 4′s Any Answers several people called in to give their views on the matter and Monday’s Woman’s Hour looked at the issue of what is home.

The topic of immigration tends to evoke certain emotions amongst people , some do not want to discuss it all because for fear of being branded racists, some put forward reasoned arguments for and against immigration whilst others persistently call for immigrants to go home, “they are taking our jobs” is another cry that we hear so often.

They were two points raised in both programmes that caught my attention

  1. Immigrants are not welcome here-  WOMAN’S HOUR
  2. if the unfairness that exists in the world such as better trade agreements were resolved there would be no need for people to come to the UK as economic immigrants.

I will discuss point one here and point two in tomorrow’s blog

Zrinka Bola one of the guests on yesterday’s  Woman’s hour made an interesting observation ” the UK is not unique in it’s attitudes towards immigrants and wherever you go you will find similar attitudes, immigrants are never welcomed”

This got me thinking about some examples of what she was talking about, remember the riots in South Africa in which several Zimbabweans died? Everyone in South African knew how bad the situation was for folk in Zimbabwe, but some in South African could not find in themselves to welcome them with open hands

I was further reminded  of a conversation I once had with a shop assistant in Kampala in Uganda. I had to have a traditional dress made at short notice so I could go to an engagement ceremony and whilst I waited, the sales assistant, asked me when and where the ceremony was and I told her in two days.

Why then are you sourcing your dress this late in the day?

I don’t live here and I didn’t know about the event until a few days ago, I replied

You sound like you live in England is that right
, Yes it is I replied

I really feel sorry for the natives of the UK, she said

I asked why

Oh, the whole world wants to go and live in the UK, they can’t have that much land
to accommodate everyone,
she continued

She then went on to say,

take Uganda (UG) for instance, in the recent years we have had had all sorts of people turn up here, Somalis, Sudanese, Nigerians, Rwandese, people from Congo and Burindi, and then more came with the troubles in Kenya. What are we going to do with all those people, they are never going home now are they?If we don’t like, I can’t imagine how the people in the UK feel about all sort of people trying to get into their country.

I am very chatty but must confess to being lost for words at this.

Another BBC Radio 4 programme gives an interesting insight about the Brits abroad and especially looks at what happened after Hong Kong was handed back to the Chinese. The presenter at some point asks whether the Brits are bad at being immigrants!

The questions is what should an immigrant at the receiving end of  violence and or  hatred do?

In tomorrow’s thread I will explore the extent to which second point (if the unfairness that exists in the world such as better trade agreements were resolved there would be no need for people to come to the UK as economic immigrants) might be true or not

In the mean time if you have a point of view please share it

Enhanced by Zemanta
Share
About ethnicsupplies

Founder of Ethnic Supplies a social enterprise working to alleviate poverty amongst East African women involved in textile and handicraft production. Managing Editor of Africa on the blog

Comments

  1. Sarah Arrow says:

    Well, that’s got me thinking Ida!

    Obviously the dislike of ‘strangers’ is part of human nature, so why do we do something that’s so against the grain? I hope something as simple as better trade agreements could make a difference, I just don’t think they are enough in the right direction (and I have no idea what would work).

    • admin says:

      I do wonder whether it is as simple as “yes you are welcome to visit but you can’t live here” I will be exploring the issue of economic migrants in the next blog but I suspect it is simply not about trade agreements either..

  2. Grace says:

    Study the laws of the land and use these to fight the injustices.

  3. idahorner says:

    If you can make sense out of those laws, that would be a good start, sadly this is not often the case. And spare a thought for those with little or no education at ll at this point. If those with a good level of comprehension are confused what chance have they got, I wonder?

  4. idahorner says:

    If you can make sense out of those laws, that would be a good start, sadly this is not often the case. And spare a thought for those with little or no education at ll at this point. If those with a good level of comprehension are confused what chance have they got, I wonder?

Trackbacks

  1. [...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Ida Horner. Ida Horner said: Immigrants are not welcome here- part 1 – the UK is not unique in it's attitudes towards immigrants and wherever yo… http://ow.ly/16ZVNI [...]

  2. [...] Immigrants are not welcome here- part 1 [...]

Speak Your Mind

*

CommentLuv badge