Can development happen without local community involvement?

 

Earlier this week I had to write an article for a magazine about the work of the Charity Let Them Help Themselves Out Of Poverty in Ruhanga SW Uganda. I was thrown back to that August day in 2008 when I arrived at project. It was a very hot and I couldn’t wait to Kabale, which is further, SW and much cooler.

 

Whilst at the project I met two women from the women’s group as well as a man (George) that was overseeing the project that day.  At the time my colleagues and I here in the UK were in the middle of organizing a fund raising dinner and dance to raise money to get piped water to the village.

 

I asked George and the women what they thought the village needed the most. George told me that a nursery school was important and led me to what I can only describe as chicken shed and said

 

Look at this, this is where our children do their lessons and because of their age we can’t send them to the government school because it is too far away

 

I too could see that something had to be done about the conditions in which the children were learning. However when we rejoined the women and I asked them what they thought were the village priorities, the answer was WATER.

 

We desperately need clean water as we current have to walk several miles to access any water at all and that water is hared with livestock

 

Fast forward to 2012 and we do have a school that provides free education to 400 children thanks to our child sponsors and we completed the piped water program last year, there are 20 taps dotted around 3 village cells. We have a community resource centre where local teachers and the youth in the community are given computer lessons by overseas volunteers and a local women teaches women in the village the art of dress making. As of last month work has started on the construction of a Community Health Centre

 

As I put all this on paper I asked myself a question

 

Could we have achieved any of this without the community under the leadership of Denis Aheirwe the local chairman?

 

The answer is a resounding NO

 

How could we? Denis has negotiated any thing and everything that needs negotiating on the ground including getting the rest of the community  on board and with the best will the world we could not have managed this regardless of how much money we might have had behind us.

 

The roles are very clear, we find the money the community does the work, they hire builders, engineers, get necessary permissions from local government  and above all oversee all the capital projects as and when they arise and above all manage the project with minimal input from us on a day to day basis.

 

In mind therefore with all the money in the world the this project could not have happened with the involvement of the community and community leaders. If you don’t believe me, check out Madonna stories, with all the gazillions dollars to her name she could erect a school in a Malawi.

 

I would really love to hear your views and or experiences on this issue

Enhanced by Zemanta

Villages in Action – I would like to hear more of these conversations

Happy New Year folk. 

How are you getting on with your New year’s resolutions so far?

I know this is an odd question but what exactly are New year’s resolutions? Are the goals or aspirations?

I recently stumbled across an an article by Linda Raftree with her wishes for the year 2012 specifically on issues of Inclusion, openness and authenticity.

Linda reflects on the events that have shaped the world in 2011 and her  wish for 2012 is for the voices of the excluded to be included in development conversations amongst other things.  I share Linda’s wish for  more  Inclusion and authentic stories especially on Africa in 2012.

I attend several events on the development  of Africa throughout the year, where I hear from development experts, academics, NGOs and big corporations and I always feel something is missing from these conversations- the voices of the recipients of  development programmes. As I recently learned if we don’t listen- WE GET IT WRONG and send out the wrong message about those that are on the receiving end of development programmes

An ordinary man on the streets of any given western capital tends to learn about Africa from a television set. This median does not always pull together those authentic stories about life in Africa and anyone with no knowledge of Africa would be forgiven for thinking that Africa is a lost cause on which resources should not be wasted.

In his BBC Radio 4 interview Mo Ibrahim has (quite rightly) recently complained about the popular media failing to present a comprehensive image of Africa.

But the  question  is who has the right to tell the authentic story of Africa ?

How do we add their voice to the development conversation and why is it important that we hear these voices?

If we learned anything in 2011 I would like to think that it was the citizens who own the right to tell their story and that social media has made that possible consequently  the world has changed in ways we could never have imagined. Social media platforms enabled ordinary citizens to take action and oust the big men of politics and the rest of us to rally around those citizens.  We heard the voices of those citizens!



Villages in Action- Is a  little unknown conference that came about in response to the UN summit of 2010. The Villages in Action platform gives us  a rare opportunity to hear from residents of a Ugandan village- we learn how they live, what they do to generate income, the impact of their lifestyle on their environment and why development initiatives do not work.

Why don’t we have more of these platforms across the world? Better still why aren’t conversations on development based on this model?

In 2012 the first development event I will attend will be in Masindi NW Uganda on 14 January 2012. This will be the second Villages in Action conference and I am really looking forward to it. If you  can’t join us you will not miss out, the organisers will bring the event live to you in your living room.

What ever the new year holds in stock- like Linda my wish for 2012 is to hear more from those at the receiving end of development!

Happy New year and please do share your New Year’s wishes

Enhanced by Zemanta

Do UK African diaspora have a role in achieving the MDGs?

 

 

On Thursday 29th September 2011 a reception was held at the UK Parliament. The theme of the reception was

Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) and the Role of  the UK African Diaspora

The reception was hosted by AFRICA -UK working in partnership with Comic Relief and the Royal African Society their objectives are to

  1. to increase the role of the Diaspora in Africa’s development
  2. to ensure that the Diaspora inform debates about development priorities for Africa
  3. and to foster greater dialogue and engagement between policy makers and UK-based Africans working in development

These were the opening remarks from the organisers

In 2000, 189 nations made a promise to free people from extreme poverty and multiple deprivations. This pledge became the eight Millennium Development Goals to be achieved by 2015. In September 2010, the world recommitted itself to accelerate progress towards these goals. ‘‘At the midway point between their adoption in 2000 and the 2015 target date for achieving the MDGs, Sub-Saharan Africa is not on track to achieve any of the Goals.”(United Nations, Africa, & the Millennium Development Goals, 2007)

What is the role of Africa’s Diaspora in helping Africa accelerate and attain the MDGs by the target date of 2015?

The speaker was  Amalia Navarro from the UN Millennium Campaign. She spoke passionately and frankly about the Goals, precisely that the goals will not be met and that the UN overlooked the diaspora in that conversation.

She also seemed to be saying “Yes we messed up but we need to look beyond2015″ and was keen to engage us on what I would like to call an “the After party”

 

She asked  the question WHAT CAN THE AFRICAN DIASPORA BRING TO THE CONVERSATION ABOUT MDGs in the same breath as she said WHERE ARE THE AFRICAN DIASPORA AND WHY AREN’T THEY JOINING IN ON THE CONVERSATION?

I did wonder where she was looking for the African diaspora or whom she was talking to.

 

What I found interesting was that at least 3 people in the room asked the speaker the following questions

  1. What does the UN want from the African Diaspora?
  2. How can the African Diaspora join the conversation?
  3. What is the UN doing to engage the diaspora

But she didn’t seem to have an answer to any of those questions and instead told us to join civil societies  in order to join the conversation on MDGs and even then she could name one such society that we could all join.

I made the assumption that she meant the large NGOs but like many in the room that evening  I am not aware of any large NGOs that seek out or engage the African diaspora, do you??

As it is we are ahead of the UN we got fed up being invited to the conversation and started our own  VILLAGES IN ACTION . We have also had a conversation about what the point of the UN is. We have a very good idea as to why the MDGs will not be achieved and this is not because we have picked up a book, No we have gone back to our villages and engaged with the folk we left behind. These are the people in the know, if you take time out they will tell you how you cannot solve poverty without sacrificing the environment in some way , they see and experience environmental degradation first hand.

The question for the UN is how to reach such  folk! But it isn’t that hard really- TALK TO THE AFRICAN DIASPORA

 

 

 

 

 

 

Enhanced by Zemanta