Ending poverty in Africa- Trade not AID model

Yesterday, I introduced the notion that ending poverty in Africa was not simply about giving more money. I asked the question why governments were not promoting more sustainable models.

A model that I am especially interested in is called RAISE TRADE, and the idea behind this concept is the move away from exporting of raw materials from developing nations and adding value else where. The founder of this model Neil Kelsall is the brains behind a very successful Malagasy chocolate based on the RAISE TRADE model. This model departs from the models that enable cooperatives in Africa to simply own shares of companies as the well as the Fairtrade models, and enables value to be added at source which increases income for the producer as well as the government through tax revenues which is not possible if value is added elsewhere.

How might this work in practice?

Take OTTIMO CAFFE, a specialist coffee roaster from North London looking to source his coffee in a more ethical way, a Uganda based coffee cooperative looking to add value to their coffees before the coffee is exported, so they can earn a higher price for their produce, a government looking to earn more tax revenue from its cash crop ,  an investor looking to invest in a socially responsible venture, that will bring him good returns at the same time and finally a retailer who must source his products more ethically because his customers demand it!

Everyone of these people have some expertise to bring to the table and the overall goal here is to produce a fully processed coffee that can be exported to the western world at the Cooperative headquarter in Uganda. This is indeed that live case that I am involved in and I have been responsible for bringing all the parties together. I must add that it is early days yet as we work the details out but all the parties are in agreement that this is the way forward in the fight against poverty.

If this model is that fantastic I hear you say, why isn’t it being adopted on a much wider scale? Well that is the question I would like an answer too. But one thing  is certain, this is doable and Neil has proved that. Is it therefore a case of committment on the aprt of decision makers, Businesses, Retailers or investors? Who is responsible for making this practice wide spread?

The fashion industry has in many ways lead the way in the VALUE ADD movement, they have however let themselves down by unfair practices especially the working conditions of the producers, we have all heard about PRIMARK being associated to the so called sweat shops.

Do you have a view on any of the issues raised here? Please share it, in the meantime take a look at Neil’s presentation below.

[slideshare id=703021&doc=raisetrade-management-services-1225309425224508-9]

In the next blog, I will bring to life a conversation I had with the CEO of the Investment Facility of Africa and you will learn why poverty in Africa is simply not about money

  • Share/Bookmark

Women's Rights are we there yet?

The economic, social and political rights are being discussed all over the media today

In the article for instance Helen Loveless argues that women are the key to recovery from the economic down turn

http://www.mailonsunday.co.uk/money/article-1160219/Women-possess-potential-create-extra-150-000-new-companies-year-hold-key-recovery.html

As a woman entrepreuner, I agree with some of the issues raised in the article such as the fear of getting into date as well as lasck of confidence. I do wonder hwoever if these issues are unique to women and would be interested in views on this from both men and women.

The best news I have read today is in the Independent on Sunday

http://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/fashion/news/cheap-cheerful-and-ethical-primark-says-it-can-be-done-1639764.html

You will recall that I wrote about Primark and their unethical practices

http://ethnicsupplies.wordpress.com/2009/01/13/%E2%80%9Cethical%E2%80%9D-primark-sources-clothing-from-sweat-shops/

I am very encouraged that they have taken steps to right a bad situation. The issue about cheap fashion is that women in the developing world are not paid a fair wage for their efforts. As this is International Women’s day, why not take a stand against un ethical fashion/clothes.  You may argue that you can’t afford to financially, and I would suggest that the way around this is to buy a few decent, ethical pieces as there are likely to last and will always look good. We are all struggling financially and this is definitely not the time to  buy cheaply, as this may mean replacing your wardrobe every 6 weeks!!

Whilst the BBC Political Show spoke to 3 women and Harriet Herman on the rights and wrongs of equal pay amongst other things

  • Share/Bookmark

“Ethical” Primark sources clothing from Sweat Shops

Primark is in the news again for selling cheap clothes from unethical sources. Both the BBC and channel 4 have reported time and time again about the plight of people that enable Primark to sell their clothes cheaply and earn huge profits for themselves

For details of the news items follow these links

http://www.channel4.com/news/articles/uk/shops+criticised+for+foreign+workers+pay/2869057

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/7824291.stm

A previous story line reported that Primark was sourcing clothes from an Indian factory that use children from refugee camps to embroider tops, sweaters and cardigans. There was an uproar amongst my colleagues and friends, specifically that according to the programme Primark reacted by dropping this particular supplier instead of working with him to ensure that his working practices improve.

One of my colleagues had a differing view from the rest of us, which has got me thinking following the latest storyline. He was of the opinion that these people need jobs and we need cheap clothes and therefore companies like Primark fulfil both our needs and therefore it is a Win Win Win situation. I recall being so appalled by that statement that I was totally lost for words

My questions today are

1. Given the credit crunch and current economic down turn are we seeking cheaper and cheaper clothing and therefore the likes of Primark are merely meeting our demands

2. If that is the case should we then be appalled when we learn how our clothes are produced/sourced or are we being hypocritical in our views

3. Can corporations such as Primark realistically check that their products are from ethical sources?

4. If you are reading this what will you do differently as a result?

I do not buy clothes at Primark for my personal use for several reasons,  some of which can that can be found at my other blog Ethnic Supplies but I admit to shopping there once when I wanted cheap clothing to send to African children in the slums of Kampala Uganda.

  • Share/Bookmark